Disturbing Incident of Anti-Semitism in U.S. School
A good friend of ours in San Francisco sent us the AP article printed below from yesterday’s San Francisco Chronicle. A report on the incident appeared the previous day in Haaretz (followed by extensive comments from readers) and in Missouri newspapers but has not received national media attention.
Friday, October 24, 2008 (SF Chronicle)
Students to be punished for ‘Hit a Jew Day’
Jim Salter, Associated Press
(10-24) 04:00 PDT St. Louis –
At least four students from a suburban St. Louis middle school face
punishment for allegedly hitting Jewish classmates during what they called
“Hit a Jew Day.”
The incident happened last week at Parkway West Middle School in
Chesterfield.
District officials said Thursday they believe that fewer than 10 of the
district’s 35 Jewish students were struck.
District spokesman Paul Tandy said that in most cases, the students were
hit on the back of their shoulders; one student was slapped in the face.
It began with an unofficial “Spirit Week” among sixth-graders that started
harmlessly enough with a “Hug a Friend Day.” Then there was “High Five
Day.”
Soon, though, the days moved from friendly to silly. Next there was “Hit a
Tall Person Day” and, finally, “Hit a Jew Day.”
District officials believe a handful of children were directly involved.
Those who actually struck classmates could face suspension and required
counseling, Tandy said. Others who weren’t directly involved but taunted
Jewish students or egged on classmates could face lesser penalties.
“There is a mix of sadness and outrage,” Tandy said. “The concern is a lot
of kids knew about it and they didn’t take action or say anything.”
Karen Aroesty, St. Louis regional director of the Anti-Defamation League,
said this was more than a case of bullying. Officials from the group will
meet Friday with district leaders to discuss the matter.
Our San Francisco friend teaches a Psychology course in a college in that city and last week the presidential election came up in a classroom discussion. One student expressed his annoyance that Obama had chosen to “meet with those AIPAC Jews.”
The remark reminded this editor of the first time she heard “Jews” being dismissively referred to in public. It was on a train in the spring of 04 and the people behind me were talking about Mel Gibson’s “Passion” movie. “The Jews are pissed off about it,” one man said. Half a year later, I heard in a small town’s peace group a discussion about Israel and the Palestinians turn into an anti-Semitic gab fest. In the same town four years later a friend at a bus-stop overheard adolescents intoning a schoolyard ditty that included the words “dirty Jew.” A few days later, on the bus, in conversation with another passenger, she heard him questioning why his brother, a commodities trader in Chicago, would “want to crawl around on the floor with Jews.”
These are merely the incidents of which only one person has direct knowledge.
Now this incident in a middle school in the American heartland indicates an escalation in the expression of anti-Jewish sentiment. These kids are simply picking up on what’s floating around.
While we don’t think the incident should be blown out of proportion, we believe it deserves serious attention and discussion because of implications beyond one sixth grade in a Missouri middle school.
Remembering the past is not necessarily a defense against it. The San Francisco Jewish Community Center, for instance, is now showing a series of films about Italian Jews during the Holocaust and will have a speaker next week about the massacres of Jews in Ukraine during World War II. American JCC’s frequently present Holocaust-related programs. But they should not take place in a vacuum. There should be a connection made with what happened at the U.N. a few weeks ago when Ahmadinejad called for the annihilation of Israel in a speech which received applause.
Perhaps the old adage that those who don’t remember the past are condemned to relive it should be changed to those who don’t connect with the past…
In a post last month we quoted ADL director Abraham Foxman stating that “the most lethal form of hatred that could be directed against the Jewish people was delivered from the platform of the United Nations and that no other such diatribe against any other religious or ethnic group could possibly flow from that august site.”
We are glad that the ADL is becoming involved in the “Hit a Jew” incident. Organizations like the Anti-Defamation League are needed now more than ever. And, as we discussed in our last post, grassroots action is also imperative.
Please help us help build a grassroots community based on common concerns and an activist perspective. Let us know your thoughts.